Recycle on Orcas Island

Recycling Tips

There’s always a lot of questions about what is and isn’t recyclable. Here are some tips for becoming a more efficient recycler on Orcas Island. Our Recycling Guidelines includes “YES” and “NO” items and also identify which items are now FREE to recycle. Please look for one of the docents if you have any questions.

Download Recycling Guidelines

Aluminum cans –Empty beverage cans only. There is signage above the bins. If you are not sure if an item is aluminum or steel, there are two magnets mounted on the post nearby – aluminum will NOT stick to the magnet, and steel will stick.

FREE to recycle, if separated.

Recycle steel cans at The Exchange.

Glass goes in dedicated bins. Caps, lids, labels and corks do not have to be removed (however, it won’t hurt if you do). Glass may be beer bottles, wine bottles, jam jars, etc., or even window glass, but NO TEMPERED glass or mirrors. There is signage above the bins.

FREE to recycle, if separated.

Recycle glass at The Exchange.

Corrugated cardboard can cause some confusion. To determine if it’s corrugated, look on an edge – if you see wavy lines, it’s corrugated. No wavy lines, then the cardboard is what we call “cereal box cardboard”, and it goes into mixed recycling bins. Sometimes the corrugation is hard to see, even with reading glasses, but I’ve found if you tear a corner of the cardboard, the corrugation will show. 

A couple more things about corrugated cardboard. Please break the box down so it is flat.  You do not need to remove tape, labels, or staples. If your boxes are really large and/or long, it helps us if you cut them to fit into the bins, allowing it to easily fit into the baler. 

Finally, the cardboard bins are under cover so that the recycler to whom we sell the bundles gets them dry – the price we get is determined by weight, so the recycler on the mainland does not want to pay for water weight.

FREE to recycle, if separated.

The hard paper corners that are used to ship a delicate or fragile item are NOT corrugated cardboard, they are compressed cardboard. They are recyclable, but go in the Mixed Recycling bins.

This is compressed cardboard, NOT corrugated, and goes into MIXED RECYCLING.

This is compressed cardboard, NOT corrugated, and goes into mixed recycling.

Before I go on to Mixed Recycling, let me explain something. In the past, we needed to send all of the above items off island. That meant costly trips on the ferry for one of the big trucks and trailers you’ve been parked next to on an early morning ferry. 

Orcas Recycling Services (ORS) has not had to ship glass off island for at least three years, and that saves us lots of weight and bulk in a trailer.

Aluminum cans have little weight, but take up a lot of room when shipped off island.

Corrugated cardboard is both bulky and heavy in a trailer, and steel (tin) cans used to always go into mixed recycling. One trailer trip to the mainland costs about $1700. The fewer trips we make, the more financially efficient we are. We like to say, “we are losing less money”.

The thing that can mess up the well-intentioned recycling effort is contamination. Since glass does not leave the island, it only gets contaminated if you put things other than eligible glass in the bin. The worst thing you can put in the glass recycling bin is a 2-liter plastic soda bottle—it clogs up the machinery and requires a time-consuming and messy repair.

If aluminum cans have other items in the bins and eventually, the bales, it can cause the recycler on the mainland to lower the price they pay us for that bale. The same goes for corrugated cardboard – too much non-corrugated cardboard, and the bale may be refused.

The “YES” segment on the recycling handout is pretty clear about what goes in those two big Mixed Recycling bins. Please make sure to keep Styrofoam items, such as food trays, out of the Mixed Recycling, as well as lids from plastic bottles – those items should be discarded in Trash.

Mixed recycling bins

The items we “DO NOT ACCEPT” are very important – plastic film, packaging materials, caps, dome tops, straws – each of the above items will contribute to a load being “contaminated”. When that happens, the whole load is treated as TRASH.

The other item that is not recyclable is “shredded paper”. You can store shredded paper in a plastic bag until you take it to the transfer station. Shredded paper goes into the TRASH bin.

Alternatively, we now offer secure document shredding at The Exchange.